Fraud Blocker
LU·English

Can I Argue Both Sides in a Duolingo English Test Writing Answer?

Yes, you can argue both sides. If you say yes in the first paragraph and no in the second, tell me what changed. In this example, the company found out the ticket ad was fake and kept showing it.

4 min read

A worker checks a paper ticket at an event entrance.
Photo by Phil Nguyen on Pexels

We were talking about social media when a student stopped me. He wanted to know if he could say yes in his first paragraph and no in his second.

Here’s the practice question I gave him in class:

“Do you agree that social media companies should be legally responsible for the content posted on their platforms?”

Who is responsible for the second ticket?

I wrote these short examples for you to compare. Imagine somebody pays for a concert ticket advertised on social media. The ticket never arrives. The buyer reports the ad, the platform confirms it’s a scam, and the ad stays up. A second person buys a ticket.

Answer A

Social media companies should be legally responsible for every fake ticket sold through ads on their platforms. They run the ads and decide who sees them.

However, the person who placed the ad is the only one who should be legally responsible for those same sales. They took the money.

Answer B

The seller should be responsible for both fake tickets. I think the platform shares responsibility once it knows the ad is fake and keeps showing it.

The first buyer’s report gave the platform a chance to take the ad down. By leaving it up after confirming the scam, the platform helped the seller reach the second buyer.

Go back to the second ticket. In Answer A, the company is responsible for every sale. Two sentences later, the seller alone is responsible for that very same ticket. Which sentence should I believe?

In Answer B, I can point to the moment the writer’s answer changes: the platform checked the report and kept the ad up. The seller is still responsible. Now I understand why the writer thinks the platform shares responsibility for the second sale, too.

You could also defend a straightforward yes or no. I ask for the condition when a student tells me, “Well, it depends.” Depends on what? Usually, what they say next belongs in the opening sentence.

What do you want your second paragraph to do?

Later in that lesson, we tried a different question. Imagine schools removed grades and exams and had teachers assess students through portfolios. Would that be a positive or negative change?

A student uses a pencil to answer questions on a printed test.
Photo by Tima Miroshnichenko on Pexels

The student asked if choosing positive meant his next point had to be positive, too. Here’s what I told him:

“If you make the thesis, there are some good and bad things, then you can talk about good and bad. It depends on how you set it up.”

In class, I acknowledged the good intentions behind the change and still judged it negatively overall. Here’s how I’d put that argument on paper. Read the sentence at the top. Can you predict what each paragraph underneath it needs to explain?

One thesis, two jobs for the paragraphs
My position
Portfolios can show how much a student has learned, but I’d keep a common exam so students at different schools are judged by the same standard.
Paragraph one
A first draft and a final draft show how a student learned to defend a claim. A single exam misses that progress.
Paragraph two
One teacher rewards improvement. Another rewards the final essay. A common exam gives both students one measure they share.

Try taking the second half off my thesis. If all I say is “Portfolios show how much a student has learned,” the paragraph about keeping exams comes as a surprise. Put those words back. Now you know why I brought up two teachers grading the same work differently.

Try it on your own answer

Go back to the fake-ticket prompt. Suppose the platform takes the ad down as soon as it confirms the first buyer’s report. Under the rule in Answer B, would the company still share responsibility for the first ticket?

Give your answer out loud. Then point to the words in the thesis that let you decide. If you can say the answer but you can’t find those words on the page, write down what you just told me. That’s often the sentence your reader was waiting for.

My answer: The seller is responsible for the first ticket. In this version, the platform removed the ad when it found out, so it never met the condition I set for sharing responsibility.

For the official task format, see Duolingo’s guide to Interactive Writing. For another exercise in finding what you’ve left for your reader to figure out, try the LU English Sandwich Test. To practice responding to a follow-up, see the LU English Interactive Writing guide.

Find your real gap

Not sure why your DET score is stuck?

Take a free practice test and see exactly where your score leaks — before you pay for the real thing.

Start the free practice test →